• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
The Red Bay News
Advertisement
  • News
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Government
  • Opinion
  • Features
    • Baymont Magazine
    • Church Directory
  • Obituaries
  • Sports
  • Classifieds
  • Events Calendar
  • Photo Gallery
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Government
  • Opinion
  • Features
    • Baymont Magazine
    • Church Directory
  • Obituaries
  • Sports
  • Classifieds
  • Events Calendar
  • Photo Gallery
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
The Red Bay News
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Judge dismisses Water and Gas lawsuit against Vinson, City of Red Bay

by Jason Collum
August 11, 2021
in News
0

More than 16 months after the Red Bay Water and Gas Board filed suit against City Councilman Jason Vison and the City of Red Bay and regarding the Council’s appointment of Vinson to the Water and Gas Board, the case has been ordered dismissed by Judge Terry Dempsey.

Dempsey issued an order of dismissal on August 4, 2021, following a motion by City of Red Bay attorney Roger Bedford, who argued the Water and Gas Board did not have standing to file the lawsuit. The order states that the “defendant can file a response within ten days consenting to the posting of a bond if he wishes. Otherwise this case will be dismissed with leave for the Plaintiff to file a new case if he so desires.”

The key issue, the City argued, is that the Water and Gas Board did not post security for costs in the case. Security for cost, according to Westlaw, “requires a plaintiff to post money into court in advance of each step of the lawsuit, thereby ensuring sufficient funds are available to the defendant if the defendant succeeds at trial.”

This apparently was not done in this case by Water and Gas, resulting in the ruling.

“It is clear from the Judge’s order, entered on August 4th, the case has not been dismissed and the court will allow this case to be refiled if the Mayor and City Council desire,” Red Bay Water and Gas Board President Ronald Thorn told The News. “(This was a) technicality that could have been raised when the suit was filed but was not raised until 15 months later and after the trial of this case had begun. Red Bay Water and Gas presumes the Mayor and Council will agree for the technicality regarding the issue of posting security for cost to be resolved by allowing Water and Gas to post security for costs, which will not harm the City in any form.”

However, that is not expected to happen as Bedford said the city was never looking for a legal fight and was following past precedent in appointing Vinson to the Board to fill a position previously held by Frankie Smith.

“The case is dismissed for a jurisdictional defect,” Bedford said. “You have to post security and costs and they didn’t do that. It doesn’t matter if it’s the first day or the fifth year into the lawsuit, they didn’t have the proper standing to file the suit. They didn’t follow the law properly.”

Thorn, however, said no order for security and costs was ever issued.

“This matter was originally filed on the 30th day of March 2020,” Thorn said. “Since the time of filing, the parties have filed various legal filings and hearings have been held.  The case was set for a final hearing on the 2nd day of July 2021. During the trial the attorney for the City requested a recess/continuance to allow him to research an issue of the authority for this matter to be filed as stated, not to raise an issue concerning security for costs not being posted when suit was filed. After the matter was recessed, the city attorney filed a Motion to Dismiss because there was no security for costs posted by Water and Gas when the suit was filed, even though no Order was entered requiring security for costs. What the City is doing is raising a technicality and this issue has not raised for 15 months.  In addition, numerous opportunities have arisen for this issue to be raised such as when other legal filings have occurred and when other proceedings have been held.”

Bedford, however, remained steadfast in the city’s position.

“Our side hasn’t been heard yet,” Bedford said. “The fact they made a mistake is not our fault.”

Appointment contested

The dispute arose following the City’s appointment of Vinson to serve on the open seat on the Water and Gas Board. From the beginning the Water and Gas Board bristled at the appointment, arguing the City could not appoint a sitting member of the Council to serve on the Board.

Thorn provided a copy of the original certificate of incorporation from 1940 to The News. That certificate states the board should consist of three members and “the board of directors shall be elected by the governing body of the Town of Red Bay. None of the members of the said board of directors shall b(e) an officer of the Town of Red Bay.” An apparent typo exists on the certificate with the word “be,” which has been corrected to “be” with handwriting.

Bedford said the certificate has been amended multiple times throughout the years, including to add additional members to bring the Board to its current number of five members. He said it had not been an issue in the past with City Council members serving simultaneously on the Board, citing Herbert Trulove and Tommy Nelson as examples. An issue did arise at one time with Nelson regarding his serving in positions both with the city and the Water and Gas Board, but that was resolved.

“Mr. Nelson remained on the Water Board as a voting member,” Bedford said. “It’s never been a problem in the past. Obviously, the City has the right to appoint them (Council members). They (Water and Gas) admit that. And it has happened in the past. But now they say they don’t want Jason to serve. The City Council has members on every board for the city.”

Thorn said the lawsuit and the Board’s stance on Vinson’s appointment has never been personal.

“The Incorporation of Red Bay Water and Gas allows the City Council to appoint any citizen to the Board except for the Mayor or City Council members,” Thorn said. “This suit was never an attempt to attack a City Council member, nor the City. This suit was filed to protect the rights of the rate payers of Red Bay, Pleasant Site, Pogo, Halltown, and Burnout by having a Board that operates independently from the City as was contemplated in the original incorporation.”

What happens next remains to be seen. The Water and Gas Board could refile the case or the two boards could begin discussions outside of court on how to proceed.

“We (the City) didn’t bring the lawsuit,” Bedford said. “This is a time when the Water Board and the City should sit down and try to work this out instead of going through litigation. The way to protect ratepayers is to allow the City and the Water and Gas Board to work hand in hand.” 

Mayor Charlene Fancher echoed this sentiment when she announced the judge’s decision at the end of last week’s Red Bay City Council meeting.

“It is our sole intention to work in harmony with all of our boards,” Fancher said. “If we don’t have communication and teamwork, we can’t make progress. Communication is very important with all of our boards and ultimately, this City Council is in charge of all other Boards in this city. I hope this is a new step toward a better direction.”

The matter could still end up in court.

“If this leads to a dismissal due to a technicality, then nothing has changed,” Thorn said. “This suit was filed to protect the rights of the rate payers of Red Bay, Pleasant Site, Pogo, Halltown, and Burnout by having a Board that operates independently from the City as was contemplated in the original incorporation. That has not changed and we will proceed accordingly to what is needed to protect the rights of the citizens we serve.”

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Tags: Charlene FancherJason VinsonRed Bay City CouncilRed Bay Water & GasRonald Thorn
Previous Post

Favorite snack, scourge of my daughters

Next Post

Census 2020: Red Bay, Franklin County gain; Belmont, Tishomingo County decline

Jason Collum

Related Posts

The 20-acre parcel of land that sits across Hwy. 19 from the Red Bay Industrial Park and Red Bay RV Park and is bordered by Ridge Road, could someday soon be the site of a new retail development if Mayor Charlene Fancher’s vision comes to pass after City officials agreed to purchase the property last week. News photo/Jason Collum
News

City purchases land with eye on commercial growth

October 27, 2021
Government

Road grant obtained for Industrial Park

June 30, 2021
Government

City sets alcohol sales vote for 2022

January 25, 2021
This caboose will soon find its way to a new home in Red Bay. Courtesy photo
Government

Donations help secure downtown lot for caboose

September 30, 2020
News

City of Red Bay issues response on COVID-19 outbreak

March 17, 2020
Mayor Charlene Fancher and the Red Bay City Council discuss the miscellaneous billing issue with Water & Gas Board member Mike Shewbart. Shewbart was the only member of that board to attend the meeting, and one of only two who responded to Fancher’s request for a joint meeting. 
News photo/Jason Collum
Government

City seeks last effort to resolve billing impasse with W&G board

January 21, 2020
Next Post
The business and industrial district of the City of Red Bay, as seen in a July 2021 aerial shot. News photo/Jason Collum

Census 2020: Red Bay, Franklin County gain; Belmont, Tishomingo County decline

Stay Connected test

  • 87.2k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Motorhomes sit outside the Tiffin Motorhomes manufacturing facility in Belmont on Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022. (News photo/Jason Collum)

Tiffin Motorhomes lays off ‘significant number’ of employees

December 5, 2022

Tiffin Group shutting down Vanleigh operations

January 9, 2023
Motorhomes sit outside the Tiffin Motorhomes manufacturing facility in Belmont on Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022. (News photo/Jason Collum)

More layoffs on the horizon for Tiffin Motorhomes

March 7, 2023

Five indicted in Red Bay childcare center infant death

June 2, 2022

Note puts school on soft lockdown

0
Members of the Mississippi Highway Patrol SWAT Team stand guard outside the home on Alice Hall Road in Itawamba County where last weekend’s murder and hostage situation took place. The immediate area was evacuated and no traffic was allowed on the road in front of the house. 
News photo/Jason Collum

Suspect dead after 32-hour standoff

0
Crews from the Red Bay Street Department worked Tuesday morning to clear debris from a home on 11th Avenue, where a retaining wall for the street collapsed, sending rip rap, mud and crossties into the home. The street has suffered significant damage from all the rain received this year.
News photo/Jason Collum

Storms pummel west Franklin County

0

Vina woman dies as car crashes into parking lot

0

Harold Lindsay

March 19, 2023
Motorhomes sit outside the Tiffin Motorhomes manufacturing facility in Belmont on Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022. (News photo/Jason Collum)

More layoffs on the horizon for Tiffin Motorhomes

March 7, 2023

Bobby McCalpin

March 6, 2023

Christy Hellums

March 5, 2023

Recent News

Harold Lindsay

March 19, 2023
Motorhomes sit outside the Tiffin Motorhomes manufacturing facility in Belmont on Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022. (News photo/Jason Collum)

More layoffs on the horizon for Tiffin Motorhomes

March 7, 2023

Bobby McCalpin

March 6, 2023

Christy Hellums

March 5, 2023
The Red Bay News

Covering the Red Bay, Vina, Belmont, Golden and western Franklin County area like no one else, since 1963.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Baymont Magazine
  • Business
  • Community
  • Crime
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Features
  • Food
  • Government
  • Heritage
  • Lifestyle
  • News
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • State/Regional

Recent News

Harold Lindsay

March 19, 2023
Motorhomes sit outside the Tiffin Motorhomes manufacturing facility in Belmont on Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022. (News photo/Jason Collum)

More layoffs on the horizon for Tiffin Motorhomes

March 7, 2023
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2022 The Red Bay News. An HPI publication. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result

© 2022 The Red Bay News. An HPI publication. All rights reserved.

error: Content is protected !!
Go to mobile version
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.